The oem was suspicious that the postulated level of gear mesh misalignment could not explain the tooth failures. Article pdf available in practical failure analysis 26. Tooth bending fatigue is one of the most common modes of fatigue failure in gears. While failures caused by a combination of factors occur.
Sometimes insufficient lubrication causes metaltometal contact with abrasive wear as a result. Spur gear crack propagation path analysis using finite. The following treatment of gear reliability is a gross simplification of the american gear manufacturers association agma code of practice, agma 2001. With well over a century of gear drive design, manufacture and troubleshooting behind it, philadelphia gear is proud to undertake the challenge of educating the maintenance and engineering staffs of its customers. Tooth bending fatigue failures in gears sciencedirect.
In both cases, we are interested in the tooth load, which we got from the torque, t. The effects of gear tooth thickness, pitch radius, and tooth pressure angle are considered. Fatigue failure pitting in the contact surface of a gear tooth. Gearbox diagnostics root cause failure analysis stork. National renewable energy laboratory national wind technology center. Gearbox reliability collaborative gearbox 1 failure. In this paper, selected experimental results from dgmk. Gears are moving parts in complex systems, and as a result, they tend to deal with a lot of wear and tear over time. When a failure arises from this cause there are often other adjacent teeth showing cracks at an earlier stage of development. As before, analysing and diagnosing gear failures is all about recognising the visual signs associated with typical failure modes.
There are at least four major modes of gear tooth failure that are directly related to deterioration of lubrication or. Hydraulic gear pump and motor failure analysis and repair. Helical gear, helical gear failure, failure analysis, fatigue failure. Oil filter contamination could cause bearing failure and gear tooth damage. The 37 mw gearbox had broken pinion teeth after several thousand operating hours the oem was proceeding with a tooth profile redesign to make the gear more tolerant of the misalignment to which other consultants had. Many researchers investigated dynamic properties of a gearbox with localized pitting. Hydraulic gear pump and motor failure analysis and repair guide. Dynamic modelling and vibration analysis for gear tooth crack. Several methods have been developed for the diagnosis of gear failures. The appearance of the various distress and failure modes can differ between gears that have through hardened teeth and. This is a major cause of gear failure accounting for nearly 60% of the gear failures.
It classifies, identifies, and describes the most common types of failure and provides information that will, in many cases, enable the user to identify failure modes and evaluate the degree or. These three modes will be investigated further, and the importance of using the right material to avoid these failures will be highlighted. The failure conditions can determine when and how to conduct an analysis. Toothbending fatigue is the most common mode of failure in gearing. Cause of failure may range from excessive wear to catastrophic breakage. Gear failures can be traced to mechanical problems or lubricant failure. Comparison of tooth interior fatigue fracture load. Tooth pitting is a common failure mode of a gearbox. May 29, 2018 the typical failure mode of gear couplings is that the teeth wear away from improper lubrication andor excessive misalignment until there is excessive backlash and tooth tip clearance leading to high vibration, or they become so thin they can no longer support the torque and roll over, an example which is a hub spinning inside a sleeve. Any failure to the gear system leads to the total system failure. The failure starts as a crack which is usually at the root of the tooth and proceeds across the base of the tooth until the complete tooth breaks away from the gear. The most critical function provided by lubricants is to minimize friction and wear to extend equipment service life. Gearbox reliability collaborative gearbox 1 failure analysis report.
Adhesive and abrasive wear are important modes of wear. A comparison of tooth interior fatigue fracture load capacity with the predicted bending and pitting fatigue capacities, as calculated according to standards. In this paper, nonentire tooth meshing testing for 20crh helical gears was performed on a closed electric power streaming gear test machine. It also gives methods for preventing gear tooth failures. In this paper the experimental results of a number of research projects with greases ranging from nlgi 00 to nlgi 1 using the fzg backtoback gear test rig are evaluated in context. Failure in a gear train can in many cases be prevented. At the same time, where the driven tooth addendum surface is in compression, fatigue can not occur. In 1973 shipley divided gear failure in their frequency of occurrence. The fatigue in the gears induces the formation of cracks in the root of the gear tooth which propagates with each rotational cycle of the gear and ultimately leads to the failure of the gear tooth. The annulus gear wear pattern indicated that the load distribution was heavier at the rotor end of the teeth.
Wear describes a loss or removal of material of gear flanks. An understanding of these four common modes will enable you to identify the cause of failure. A study was performed to evaluate fault detection effectiveness as applied to geartooth pittingfatigue damage. Special purpose couplings are used on this equipment in.
The gear failure is explained by means of flow diagram in. Effects of several methods that can be used to mitigate tiff risk are evaluated based on their performance, with respect to the other failure modes. Agma 1010 appearance of gear teeth terminology of wear. Table 1 lists six general classes of gear failure modes, of which the first four are the most common. In terms of gear failure, it is more a deterioration of a gear profile, for instance, a damage of a tooth layer. Contact fatigue failure criterion when the single tooth pitting area rate achieves 4% or the gear pair pitting area rate achieves 0. Gear specification data 911a94 9 design guidelines for aerospace gearing 912a04 9 mechanisms of gear tooth failure 9a98 10 method for specifying the geometry of spur and helical gears 914b04 10 gear sound manual part i. For example, after a disc pack diaphragm fracor s or tureafter severe gear tooth wear, our vibration interlock set points and. The gears normally fail at two different regions of the gear tooth flank or tooth root. The oem was proceeding with a tooth profile redesign to make the gear more tolerant of the misalignment to which other consultants had attributed the tooth failures. The appearance of the various distress and failure modes can differ between gears that have through hardened teeth and those that have surface hardened teeth.
Tooth bending, surface contact pitting or spalling, rolling. In this presentation, i introduce many examples to understand such model of tooth flank failures. In an analysis of more than 1,500 gear failure studies, the three most common failure modes were toothbending fatigue, toothbending impact, and abrasive tooth wear 4. Oil analysis provides important information on wear modes and possible gearbox lubrication problems.
Gears wear, failure and lubrication engineers edge. Press releases american gear manufacturers association. Coupling credible failure modes and owner options to intervene. I hope, many gear researcher have an interest in these failure modes and will be encouraged to carry out research on this topic. The characteristics of this failure mode are discussed in detail and a number of actual case studies are presented which show the occurrence of this failure mode. Tooth failure is often the result of positive feedback behavior of such dynamic system of surface failure. Part 1 classifies gear tooth failures into five modes and explains the factors that a gear designer and operator must consider to avoid gear failures.
It classifies, identifies, and describes the most common types of failure and provides information that will, in many cases, enable the user to identify failure modes and evaluate the degree or change from original condition. The different modes of gear failure are as shown in figure 1. Many of the gear failure modes can be prevented if. Gear systems or gear trains tend to play a very vital role in all industries and also in our day to day life.
The root cause of the scuffing was probably trapping of debris. The typical failure mode of gear couplings is that the teeth wear away from improper lubrication andor excessive misalignment until there is excessive backlash and tooth tip clearance leading to high vibration, or they become so thin they can no longer support the torque and roll over, an example which is a hub spinning inside a sleeve. The nonhunting gear ratio, with a common factor of three, caused the damage to imprint on every third tooth. The test analysis of transmission gears fatigue pitting. The primary failure mode of the oringhollow shaft seal was severe scuffing and. Pdf failure analysis of a helical gear researchgate. The fixed displacement gear pumps utilized by alamo industrial are of a proven design and will. Metals free fulltext contact fatigue failure analysis of helical.
Some failure modes can only be prevented with sufficient system design considerations, such as operating too near a. Even flawlessly machined gears, composed of ideal materials and taken care of appropriately, can eventually fail after enough time. When it does occur, the proper redesign will ensure a trouble free unit. We have seen how to evaluate 15 the damaging fatigue load on a gear tooth, f, due to the torque transmitted combined with the quality of the gears manufacture and its operating environment. The good news is there are only five common failure modes. Bending fatigue is a failure mode that affects gear teeth. These differences result from the different physical characteristics and properties and from the residual stress characteristics associated with the surface hardened gearing. This is a threepart article explaining the principles of gear lubrication.
How to diagnose gear failures neale consulting engineers. Gear failure is therefore very much a case of fatigue, though a oneoff static overload obviously may cause failure if sufficiently large. For this reason, worm gears are used mostly for light loads. Continuing our series on articles on how to diagnose different machinery failures, this page looks at the failure of gears.
Various defects in gear the general types of failure modes in decreasing order of frequency include fatigue failure, impact fracture, wear and stress rupture. Many modes of gear failure have been identified, for example fatigue, impact, wear or plastic deformation. Pitting is the formation of craters on the gear tooth. Tooth bending and surface contact fatigue are two of the most common modes of fatigue failure found in gears. October 6, 2009, revealed that the highspeed stage gear teeth showed signs of. Msi was contracted by the oem to perform testing and analysis to determine the root cause of gear tooth failures on an aeroderivative gas turbine power generation drivetrain. Comparison of tooth interior fatigue fracture load capacity. It results in progressive damage to gear teeth and ultimately leads to complete failure of the gear. Finally, despite all of our efforts to avoid coupling failure, our installations and our personnel need be able to adequately respond to failure modes which experience shows are credible. All of these important technical aspects of gear technology are brought together in the present offering, gear materials, properties, and manufacture. This standard provides nomenclature for general modes of gear tooth wear and failure. Failures are a result of excessive cyclic bending stresses applied to teeth in. These three modes will be investigated further, and the importance of using the right material to.
In an analysis of more than 1,500 gear failure studies, the three most common failure modes were tooth bending fatigue, tooth bending impact, and abrasive tooth wear 4. Gearbox typical failure modes, detection and mitigation. Detecting gear tooth fracture in a high contact ratio face. Especially, vibration signal analysis is an efficient method for. Gear tooth failure, prevention of tooth failure, definition of gear, types of failure, bending failure, wear failure, pitting, scoring, abrasive wear failure. Lubricantrelated failures are usually traced to contamination, oil film collapse, additive depletion, and use of improper lubricant for the application. Gear failure can be divided into gear tooth flank failure like pitting, scuffing and wear or failure modes on gear root fillets, like bending, and impact. Stresses on spur gear teeth the two primary failure modes for gears are. Dec 18, 2017 gear tooth failure, prevention of tooth failure, definition of gear, types of failure, bending failure, wear failure, pitting, scoring, abrasive wear failure. To estimate the tooths life as a result of each failure mechanism, this load is applied to a geometrically simplified model of the tooth, viz. Bending fatigue failure is the result of cyclic bending stress at the tooth root. Gear tooth surface damage diagnosis based on analyzing the.
Gearbox typical failure modes, detection and mitigation methods. Three gear fault detection techniques, fm4, na4, and. This crack ends up in failure of tooth giving a halt to the whole transmission system. Learning gear essentials from dudleys handbook machine. The new combined standard expands the nomenclature for general modes of gear tooth wear and failure. Most gear tooth fatigue failures occur in the tooth root fillet where cyclic stress is much less than the yield. Grindhonepolish gear teeth superfinish, coat, or smooth bearing rings or elements avoid shotpeened flanks make hardest gear bearing element as smooth as possible. Failure analysis in study of any failure, the analyst must consider a broad spectrum of.
Gear has failed when it can no longer efficiently do the job for which it was designed. If care is taken during the design stage it to prevent each of these failures a sound gear design can be evolved. Bending fatigue failures occur when the stress at the root of the gear tooth exceeds the capability of the gear material. Five common gearbox failures and how to identify them. Of these, one of the most common causes of gear failure is tooth bending fatigue. The second of a four part article contains an indepth discussion of the gear tooth failure modes that are influenced by lubrication. Crack propagation paths are predicted for a variety of gear tooth geometry at various crack initiation location. Common gear failures gear solutions magazine your resource.
1460 61 420 41 532 1513 1280 87 548 1212 245 705 216 1382 959 1409 1002 799 1259 913 163 368 1116 760 54 938 675 1413 556 637 826 69 7 1156 187 544